The Supreme Court in the case of MAXWELL LAND-GRANT CO. v. DAWSON, 151 U.S. 586 (1894), ruled in favor of the Maxwell Land-Grant Company. The court found that the company had a valid title to the disputed land within the Beaubien-Miranda land grant, and that the defendant, John B. Dawson, did not have a valid claim through adverse possession. The court rejected Dawson's argument that the land transfer to the Maxwell Land-Grant Company was invalid under the civil law in force in New Mexico in 1868, as the court found it unnecessary to decide that issue. Ultimately, the Supreme Court upheld the company's ownership of the disputed land.